FRESH GROUND THEOLOGY

Understanding Communion: A Holy Meal for Needy People

Fresh Ground Theology logo

Understanding communion begins with Christ’s gift of himself and the welcome he offers to repentant believers. Before we take communion, we examine ourselves. That examination brings us face to face with sins we have excused, people we have treated without love, and ways we still need to change. What should we do with that discovery when the bread and the cup come to us?

I believe it should lead us to repentance and then to the Table. Our need for mercy is one of the reasons Christ gave us this meal. He calls us to confess our sins and receive what he has provided for us in his death. The holiness of communion and its comfort belong together because both come from the same Lord.

My personal statement on communion

That conviction stands behind my personal statement on communion. I understand the Supper as a covenantal meal in which we remember Christ’s sacrifice and truly commune with him through the Holy Spirit. Because we share in Christ, we must also recognize our fellowship with everyone else who belongs to him. The meal calls us to take both his grace and our belonging to one another seriously. Here is my statement in full:

Statement

We believe and confess that the Holy Communion is the covenantal meal of the Lord, ordained by Christ and delivered to His Church through the ages (1 Cor. 11:23). The bread is the sign and mystery of Christ’s most holy Body, given for us and received by faith through the Holy Spirit (Matt. 26:26; Mark 14:22; John 6:51-53). We eat this bread in remembrance of Him (Luke 22:19; 1 Cor. 11:24). The cup is the sign and mystery of the New Covenant by Christ’s own Blood poured out for many for the remission of sins and received by faith through the Holy Spirit (Matt. 26:27-28; Mark 14:24; Luke 22:20; John 6:51-53). We drink this cup in remembrance of Him (1 Cor. 11:25-26). This sacred Supper is a foretaste of the coming Kingdom (Matt. 26:29; Mark 14:25; Luke 22:15-18).

Participation

We believe Christ is not divided and His Church is one. Therefore, all who belong to Jesus—whether members of our church or of another congregation—are invited to join us in this holy celebration. All who draw near to this Holy Table must believe in the one true and living God: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. For the Eucharist is sacred fellowship with Him (1 Cor. 10:16). All who would partake must first examine themselves, discerning the unity of the Body of Christ (1 Cor. 11:27-34).

Let none approach who would sow division among the brethren—whether by wealth or poverty, race or nation, male or female, politics or creed or any such distinctions. Those who divide the body of Christ bring judgment on themselves (1Cor. 11:27-34).

Let none approach who would fellowship with idols, sware oaths to darkness, consult with spirits, commune with the dead, practice sorcery, or defile themselves with fornication, adultery, sexual abuse or any impure thing. Those who share in Christ must not partake in the table of demons (1Cor. 10:14-22).

Yet we welcome to the Table of our Lord all who repent from division and defilement, for His mercy is great, and His grace abounds to the contrite.

Thus do we confess, as the Church has always confessed, and thus do we partake until He comes in glory. Amen.

Understanding communion as a covenant meal

The statement begins with Christ’s action because his action gives the meal its meaning. Jesus appointed it, identified the bread and the cup, and instructed his disciples to receive them in remembrance of him. The church receives this meal from him and passes it on. Our first task is to understand what he gave us.

The word covenantal places the meal within the story of God bringing a people into fellowship with himself. A covenant establishes a relationship with promises and obligations. At Sinai, Moses announced the covenant and sprinkled its blood on the people. Afterward, Israel’s representatives went up the mountain and ate and drank in God’s presence. Covenant, sacrifice, and a meal belonged together in that encounter (Exodus 24:3–11).

Jesus gave the bread and the cup to his disciples in the setting of the Passover. He identified the cup with the new covenant in his blood and spoke of his blood being poured out for the forgiveness of sins. In that setting, I understand communion as the meal of the people whom his sacrifice brings into fellowship with God. Our welcome depends on what Christ has done for us (Luke 22:14–20; Matthew 26:26–29).

This also explains why remembrance matters. We eat bread and drink from the cup because Jesus gave us a particular way to remember his death. The remembrance takes the form of a shared act: we receive what he appointed and confess our dependence on the sacrifice it announces. Our thoughts and feelings participate in that act, but the act itself begins with his command and promise.

Christ’s presence and communion as a means of grace

I also believe something happens in communion beyond our recalling an event. Paul describes the cup and the bread as communion in Christ’s blood and body (1 Corinthians 10:16). His language gives me reason to speak of actual fellowship with the living Christ. Through the Holy Spirit, believers receive spiritual nourishment from the Savior whose death the meal proclaims.

That is what I mean by calling communion a means of grace. Christ uses this appointed meal to strengthen our faith and deepen our fellowship with him. The grace comes from Christ, and the Holy Spirit makes the meal fruitful in those who receive by faith. Its benefit therefore depends on his faithfulness, even when our feelings are unsettled or our attention is imperfect.

The statement’s language of sign and mystery holds together the visible gift and the spiritual reality. We receive bread and the cup with our bodies, and through them we receive the promise of Christ’s body given and blood shed for us. I believe the Spirit truly brings us into fellowship with Christ through this act, although I cannot explain his work as a physical process. The mystery concerns how he gives this fellowship; Christ himself has told us what the meal means.

Receiving Christ by faith

John 6 helps explain this dependence on Christ. Jesus speaks of eating his flesh and drinking his blood, and he also connects coming to him and believing in him with the satisfaction of hunger and thirst. Christians differ over how directly this chapter describes the Eucharist. I read its feeding language as illuminating the life we receive from Christ by faith, while Paul’s explicit discussion of the Supper in 1 Corinthians 10 provides the more direct basis for calling the meal communion with him (John 6:35–63). We explore these questions further in our conversation on the Eucharist’s presence, tradition, and mystery.

This understanding has a clear parallel in the Westminster Larger Catechism. Its answer to Question 170 describes believers as truly receiving Christ and the benefits of his death in a spiritual manner through faith. Question 172 then applies that conviction to weak and doubting Christians, explaining that they may come to be strengthened. That connection matters: if Christ uses the meal to nourish faith, weakness is a reason to seek his help there.

Understanding communion as spiritual nourishment also explains its place among the church’s practices. We continue to need nourishment because we continue to depend on Christ. His offering was sufficient once for all, as Hebrews 10:10–18 teaches, and its benefits remain sufficient for his people. Each celebration directs us again to that completed sacrifice and the living Savior who gave himself for us.

Who should take communion?

Understanding communion requires us to see how fellowship with Christ establishes our fellowship with one another. Paul moves from sharing in the bread to the unity of the people who share it (1 Corinthians 10:16–17). The same Christ receives each believer. Therefore, the person beside me comes with a claim on my love that grows out of our common belonging to him.

This is why my statement welcomes believers from other congregations. Local church membership matters, but Christ’s church extends beyond the membership of any one congregation. I believe our practice of communion should acknowledge that larger fellowship. A Christian visiting from another church belongs to the same Lord and depends on the same sacrifice.

The invitation also identifies the faith being confessed. Those who participate profess faith in the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and come as people who belong to Jesus. The meal expresses an existing fellowship with him. Someone still exploring Christianity can hear the promise it announces and witness the church’s dependence on Christ, while understanding why participation calls for faith.

Unity without contempt

The reference to division by “creed” needs to be read alongside that confession. I am speaking against using differences among fellow Christians as grounds for contempt or faction. Truth still matters, and genuine disagreements need honest discussion. Our responsibility is to pursue that discussion while recognizing the people Christ has received as our brothers and sisters.

The closing appeal to the church’s confession should be understood with the same care. Christians have long differed over how Christ is present in communion and over the boundaries of participation. This statement expresses my convictions within that history. Its appeal to continuity concerns receiving and celebrating the meal Jesus entrusted to his church; its fuller explanation expresses my own understanding of that meal.

Self-examination before communion

The practical seriousness of our fellowship becomes clear in Corinth. Some participants ate their own meals while others went hungry, and Paul accused them of humiliating those who had nothing. Their gathering was reinforcing divisions among people who belonged to the same Lord. That conduct forms the immediate setting of his warning about eating and drinking unworthily (1 Corinthians 11:17–34).

I understand the call to discern the body in light of that setting. Reverence for Christ’s body given for us must shape how we treat the people who share his meal. Economic status was the explicit problem Paul addressed; the same principle challenges our use of race, nationality, sex, or political allegiance to rank fellow believers. These differences cannot establish degrees of belonging to Christ. Our episode on communion and the Corinthian crisis examines the setting of Paul’s warning in more detail.

Self-examination therefore includes our relationships. I need to consider whom I have dismissed, whose needs I have ignored, and whether I am willing to seek reconciliation where I have done wrong. Communion gives these questions a specific urgency because I am receiving a gift shared with the very people I may have treated as beneath me.

The Lord’s Table and the table of demons

The warning about idols concerns another violation of our fellowship with Christ. In 1 Corinthians 10:14–22, Paul treats pagan sacrificial meals as participation involving real spiritual powers and forbids Christians to share in both those meals and the Lord’s Table. Yet he later permits eating food bought in the market without investigating its history. The issue is participation in idolatrous worship, rather than contamination through ordinary food. For more on that distinction, listen to our discussion of the Eucharist and pagan sacrifice.

My statement applies that demand for allegiance to practices such as consulting spirits and attempting communion with the dead. Those practices also fall under Scripture’s prohibition of divination and seeking the dead in Deuteronomy 18:9–14. Fellowship with Jesus calls us to turn from spiritual allegiances and practices that oppose him. We cannot confess his lordship at the Table while reserving part of our worship for other powers.

Sexual sin, repentance, and accountability

The warning about sexual sin draws on the same responsibility to live as people who belong to Christ. Paul addresses that responsibility directly in 1 Corinthians 6:15–20, where he connects our bodily conduct with our union with the Lord. Sexual immorality is therefore relevant to self-examination, although that chapter and the wider biblical witness supply the argument more directly than the passage about sacrificial meals alone.

Where abuse is involved, repentance must include ending the harm and accepting accountability. A confession spoken before communion cannot substitute for that turning. Likewise, a person who tells the truth about being harmed is not thereby sowing division. The unity Christ gives us calls us to protect one another and address wrongdoing honestly.

Understanding communion through repentance and grace

These warnings require repentance, and repentance involves a real change of direction. Someone who intends to continue harming others or worshiping idols has reason to stop and face what that intention means. A believer who confesses sin and seeks Christ’s help is responding differently, even when the struggle has been long and the work of change remains difficult.

Paul’s instruction in 1 Corinthians 11:28 gives self-examination its direction: examine yourself, “and so let him eat.” The warning calls us to approach in a manner fitting the meal. It does not establish sinlessness as the condition of admission. The person who discovers sin must bring that discovery into repentance and faith.

This is where the statement’s welcome to the contrite becomes necessary. A contrite person is grieved by sin and willing to turn from it. Such a person may still feel ashamed, uncertain, or weak. Those feelings do not cancel Christ’s mercy, and they do not make his provision less sufficient.

When examination shows me how much I need forgiveness, I should take that need seriously enough to seek the forgiveness Christ gives. When it shows me a relationship I need to repair, I should begin the work of repair. In each case, the examination directs me toward reliance on Christ and obedience to him. Communion then strengthens the faith by which I continue that work.

Communion and the coming kingdom

The invitation finally reaches beyond the present struggle. Jesus spoke of drinking with his disciples in his Father’s kingdom (Matthew 26:29), and that promise gives the meal its forward movement. We receive it as people waiting for the Lord who died for us to return and bring our fellowship with him to its fullness.

The accompanying hymn gives that hope a fitting expression:

O sacred feast! O foretaste bright
Of Heaven’s coming King!
We drink the cup, we walk in light,
And of Thy triumph sing!

Understanding communion in light of that hope brings our confession of sin and our confidence in Christ together. The Savior who knows our need has given himself for us, receives us by grace, and promises us a place in his coming kingdom. We can therefore confess honestly, repent sincerely, and receive the bread and the cup with thanksgiving. Our need is great, and his provision is sufficient.

If you want to keep investigating Scripture’s puzzles with us, begin with our communion conversation. Then follow Fresh Ground Theology on Apple Podcasts and join us for the next question over coffee.

Topic: , ,
Related subjects

Leave a Reply