FRESH GROUND THEOLOGY

Does the Divine Council Mean the Bible Teaches Many Gods?

Fresh Ground Theology logo

Open your Bible expecting one God, and Psalm 82 hands you an assembly of gods. God stands among them and announces their judgment, which sounds like the sort of meeting where nobody volunteers to take the minutes. If you learned that the word “God” can refer only to the Creator, you may wonder how this assembly got into Scripture.

Hear our conversation on who the Old Testament calls “gods”.

The divine council does not require Christians to believe in several gods who share Yahweh’s identity or deserve our worship. Scripture describes a populated heaven while distinguishing Yahweh, Israel’s God, from everyone he created. The question about divine council and polytheism therefore requires us to examine what these beings are called, what Yahweh does, and whom Scripture tells us to worship.

What does elohim mean?

The Hebrew word elohim can refer to the God of Israel or to other beings called gods. Its grammatical form is plural, but its use is not always plural. In Genesis 1:1, elohim is the subject of a singular verb: God creates. The sentence describes one Creator, not several gods working on a joint construction project.

Psalm 82 uses the same word for the God who judges and for the gods who receive his judgment. The opening distinguishes the presiding God from the members of the assembly. The rest of the psalm explains why those members are being judged:

God standeth in the congregation of the mighty; he judgeth among the gods. How long will ye judge unjustly, and accept the persons of the wicked? Selah. Defend the poor and fatherless: do justice to the afflicted and needy. Deliver the poor and needy: rid them out of the hand of the wicked. They know not, neither will they understand; they walk on in darkness: all the foundations of the earth are out of course. I have said, Ye are gods; and all of you are children of the most High. But ye shall die like men, and fall like one of the princes. Arise, O God, judge the earth: for thou shalt inherit all nations.

Psalm 82:1–8

Some interpreters understand these gods as human judges, but I prefer the heavenly interpretation. The description of them as children of the Most High, their sentence to die like human beings, and the heavenly assembly described in Psalm 89:5–7 fit that reading together. These are supernatural rulers held accountable for injustice, and their title gives them no immunity from judgment. Our podcast Who Are the “Gods” of the Old Testament? The Supernatural Worldview follows these beings through the wider biblical story.

Michael S. Heiser explains this use of elohim in his study of divine plurality and monotheism. He describes it as a “place of residence” term: it identifies beings belonging to the spiritual world without assigning all of them the same abilities or status. On his reading, calling a being an elohim does not establish that it is eternal, created everything, or deserves worship. We have to learn those things from what the biblical writers say about that being.

Monotheism, monolatry, and henotheism

Several terms help identify the questions involved. Some concern how many gods people recognize, while others concern whom they worship. Keeping those questions distinct prevents a discussion about vocabulary from becoming a disagreement about something else.

TermBasic meaning
MonotheismBelief in one God. Christian theology identifies this God as the sole uncreated Creator.
PolytheismBelief in multiple gods, often arranged in a hierarchy.
MonolatryWorship of one god while accepting the existence of other gods.
HenotheismDevotion to one god as supreme while recognizing other gods.

A polytheistic religion can have a supreme god, so a heavenly hierarchy alone does not establish biblical monotheism. We need to ask whether Yahweh is simply the strongest member of that hierarchy or whether the other beings depend on him for their existence. The biblical claims about creation bring that distinction into view.

What makes Yahweh unique?

Israel’s confession begins with Yahweh himself: “Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God is one LORD” (Deuteronomy 6:4). The next verse commands Israel to love him with all its heart, soul, and might. That confession directs the whole person toward Yahweh, leaving no portion of Israel’s allegiance to distribute among other gods. Psalm 86:8–10 brings this exclusive allegiance into direct conversation with the language of other gods:

Among the gods there is none like unto thee, O Lord; neither are there any works like unto thy works. All nations whom thou hast made shall come and worship before thee, O Lord; and shall glorify thy name. For thou art great, and doest wondrous things: thou art God alone.

Psalm 86:8–10

The psalm begins by comparing Yahweh with the gods and ends by declaring that he alone is God. Between those statements, it describes the nations coming to worship him. Yahweh’s claim reaches beyond Israel because he made the nations themselves. Their existence gives them a relationship to their Creator that their different national religions cannot cancel.

Nehemiah 9:6 extends the claim of creation to heaven itself: “Thou, even thou, art LORD alone; thou hast made heaven, the heaven of heavens, with all their host, the earth, and all things that are therein, the seas, and all that is therein, and thou preservest them all; and the host of heaven worshippeth thee.” The heavenly host belongs among the things Yahweh made and continues to sustain. Its members depend on the God before whom they bow. They cannot be additional uncreated gods alongside him, because the prayer places them within his creation.

Yahweh’s authority also includes the course of history. In Isaiah 44:6–8, he challenges any supposed competitor to demonstrate the knowledge and authority that he possesses. Israel can trust its Redeemer because his claim is supported by his government of events:

Thus saith the LORD the King of Israel, and his redeemer the LORD of hosts; I am the first, and I am the last; and beside me there is no God. And who, as I, shall call, and shall declare it, and set it in order for me, since I appointed the ancient people? and the things that are coming, and shall come, let them shew unto them. Fear ye not, neither be afraid: have not I told thee from that time, and have declared it? ye are even my witnesses. Is there a God beside me? yea, there is no God; I know not any.

Isaiah 44:6–8

Yahweh identifies himself as the first and the last, then asks who can declare what is coming as he does. His knowledge of history supports his command that Israel should not be afraid. The following verses expose the absurdity of trusting an idol that a craftsman has made from the same wood he uses to cook dinner (Isaiah 44:9–20). A god who depends on somebody’s leftover firewood is a poor candidate for governing the future.

These passages give substance to the claim that Yahweh rules the heavenly world. He creates its inhabitants, sustains their lives, and exercises authority that they cannot match. Our podcast What Is Spiritual Warfare? The Old Testament View explores how this kingship shapes the Bible’s accounts of conflict with other spiritual powers.

Why does Israel’s heavenly council resemble its neighbors’?

Israel’s neighbors also described divine assemblies, and the texts from Ugarit give us a particularly useful comparison. Ugarit was an ancient city on the coast of what is now Syria. Its clay tablets preserve stories about gods whose relationships help explain the religious setting of the Old Testament.

In these stories, El is the elder divine patriarch, while Baal is a storm and warrior god associated with rain and royal power. Other deities belong to the divine assembly, and messages, disputes, and decisions pass through that assembly. The gods have relationships and interests of their own. A council of gods was therefore a recognizable part of the ancient religious world in which Israel’s traditions took shape.

The resemblance helps us understand why biblical writers describe heavenly government through a king and his court. It also raises a historical question about the relationship between Israel’s religion and the religions around it. Answering that question requires comparing the texts’ claims about their gods, as well as noticing that they use similar scenes.

What do Cross, Smith, and Heiser disagree about?

We need to distinguish interpreting a passage from reconstructing the history behind it. The first asks what a text says about Yahweh and the other beings in its present form. The second asks how Israel’s beliefs developed, how its traditions relate to neighboring traditions, and when particular claims emerged. A proposal about that history requires an argument beyond identifying the word elohim in a verse.

The Bible itself describes Israelites worshiping other gods. King Manasseh of Judah worships the heavenly host and builds altars for it in the temple courts, practices the account condemns as evil (2 Kings 21:2–5). The passage records polytheistic worship while rejecting it. We therefore need to distinguish the religion practiced by particular Israelites from the worship a biblical author commends.

Frank Moore Cross investigated these historical relationships in Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic, first published in 1973. He examined the connections between Canaanite traditions, the worship of El, and Israel’s portrayal of Yahweh. Yet Cross did not treat every occurrence of El as evidence for a god distinct from Yahweh. In his discussion of Psalm 82, he understood El as a name for Yahweh within the psalm and questioned the proposal that Yahweh was standing in a separate god’s council (pp. 44–45). His work shows why we should examine a scholar’s reading of a particular passage before assigning him a position in a general debate.

Mark S. Smith’s The Origins of Biblical Monotheism, published in 2001, investigates Israelite monotheism against its polytheistic background. Smith studies the relationship between El and Yahweh and argues that Israel’s exclusive religious identity developed over a long period within its Canaanite setting. In his reconstruction, the Sinai account expresses a religious identity that developed later. He also treats declarations of Yahweh’s exclusive deity as language reinforcing Israel’s relationship with its God. His account therefore concerns the historical formation of that commitment as well as the purposes those declarations served.

Heiser challenges the inference that a biblical council of gods demonstrates that its authors regarded Yahweh as one deity of the same kind as the others. His 2004 dissertation follows divine council language into later biblical and Second Temple Jewish literature, showing that the language continued after the Babylonian exile. That continuity is central to his objection: the heavenly assembly did not simply disappear when Jewish writers affirmed the uniqueness of Israel’s God. His explanation combines the continued existence of heavenly beings with their dependence on Yahweh and his incomparability.

On the theological question, I agree with Heiser that the assembly’s existence is compatible with Yahweh’s unique deity. Nehemiah’s prayer gives a direct reason for that conclusion: Yahweh made and sustains the heavenly host. The distinction between Yahweh and these beings concerns their very existence, extending beyond the authority he exercises over them.

How should Christians read these passages together?

Paul brings the question into Christian worship in 1 Corinthians 8. He acknowledges beings called gods and lords, then states the church’s confession: “But to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by him” (1 Corinthians 8:6). Paul identifies the Father as the source of all things and Jesus Christ as the one through whom all things exist. Jesus therefore cannot be placed among the created members of the heavenly council.

The heavenly beings belong to the creation that owes its existence to God. Historic Christian confession of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit concerns the identity of the one God. It does not turn the heavenly assembly into additional members of the Trinity.

That distinction also governs the response we owe other spiritual beings. Their existence and power do not establish a right to receive our worship. In Should Christians Worship the Divine Council? Arnobius Against Paganism, I examine an early Christian argument that grants the possibility of subordinate divine beings while directing worship to the Creator who rules them. Acknowledging a being and giving that being our allegiance are different acts.

Revelation 22:8–9 makes the proper response concrete when John falls down before the angel who has shown him the visions. The angel identifies himself as a fellow servant and tells John to worship God. The heavenly being’s glory does not change his place among God’s servants. The church belongs with those servants, joining the heavenly host in worship of the God who made them.

Topic: ,
Related subjects

Leave a Reply